In this guide

Enhance brand reputation for long-term success

    Enhance brand reputation for long-term success

    Strengthen brand perception, refine messaging, and maintain consistency across every touchpoint to build credibility, increase engagement, and stay ahead in a rapidly evolving market.

    Digital assets for the UserTesting guide “Enhance brand reputation for long-term success”

    Your brand’s reputation isn’t built overnight—but it can unravel in an instant. In today’s digital world, perception is everything. A single misstep in messaging, a tone-deaf campaign, or a poor customer experience can trigger massive backlash, damaging years of brand equity. 

    Yet, many brand leaders struggle to answer a critical question: How do customers truly perceive us? Traditional brand studies are too slow, and internal perspectives are often biased, leaving brands blind to risks until it’s too late. In today’s fast-moving landscape, the wrong message, ad, or campaign can spark backlash in minutes, reshaping customer perception before a brand even has time to react. 

    This guide provides a proven playbook for strengthening your brand’s reputation. Learn how leading companies refine messaging, validate storytelling, and ensure their brand stays authentic, consistent, and culturally relevant across every touchpoint.  Instead of scrambling to fix perception problems after they arise, you'll discover how to proactively shape your brand’s reputation before it’s defined for you.

    Your brand reputation is everything—are you managing it effectively?

    From messaging to crisis response, every decision shapes your brand’s reputation

    Today’s consumers have unlimited access to information and more choices than ever before. They expect brands to be transparent, authentic, and consistent across every interaction. But with social media amplifying both praise and criticism in real time, brand reputation is more fragile—and more critical—than ever. According to a 2024 Branding Statistics report by Capital One Shopping Research 75% of consumers aged 18 to 34 consider brand trust more important than in the past. 

    While trust plays a role, it’s only one piece of the puzzle. Brand reputation is built on multiple factors, including trust, awareness, consistency, customer experience, corporate responsibility, and crisis management. Considering these factors, many organizations struggle to maintain a strong, consistent reputation while keeping pace with evolving customer expectations.   

     

    Brand perception is always evolving—are you keeping up?

    Brands that fail to actively manage their reputation face significant risks:

    • Loss of customer trust: A single misstep in messaging or positioning can lead to public backlash.
    • Missed engagement opportunities: Brands that don’t resonate with audiences lose market share to competitors who do.
    • Wasted marketing spend: Without validating messaging, brands risk pouring resources into ineffective campaigns.
    • Slower growth and revenue decline: Studies show that companies with strong brand perception enjoy higher loyalty, pricing power and increased spending from returning customers.
    • Weaker brand recognition: Inconsistent messaging or a lack of visibility leads to diminished brand recall.
    • Crisis amplification: Poor handling of crises can escalate brand damage rather than contain it.

    In an era of instant feedback and viral consumer sentiment, a brand’s reputation can shift overnight. To maintain a strong, consistent reputation while keeping pace with evolving customer expectations, companies must proactively monitor and refine their brand strategy across all touchpoints—before perception gaps turn into major setbacks.

    Building a great brand is hard. Keeping it strong? Even harder

    Despite the high stakes, many organizations find it difficult to maintain a strong, consistent brand reputation. Here’s why:

    1. Authenticity at scale is hard to maintain

    As brands grow and expand globally, automated processes and templated messaging can dilute brand identity, making interactions feel impersonal—or even offensive across cultural contexts. (BBC). 

    2. Brand perception gaps are invisible until it’s too late

    Many companies rely on internal assumptions or historical data to make branding decisions, leading to misalignment between brand intent and actual perception. By the time problems surface in social sentiment or sales numbers, the damage is already done. 

    3. Inconsistency across channels weakens trust

    A brand’s story must be cohesive across websites, social media, advertising, and customer interactions. Disjointed messaging confuses customers and dilutes brand equity. 

    4. Cultural sensitivity issues lead to unintended backlash

    Without a deep understanding of regional and cultural nuances, brands risk alienating global audiences with tone-deaf messaging or visuals. 

    5. Traditional brand studies are too slow

    Traditional brand studies take months, while social listening tools only capture what’s happened—like looking in the rearview mirror. are like looking in the rearview mirror. Without real-time insights, brands are left reacting instead of shaping perception. And by the time a reputation issue surfaces, the damage is often already done.

    6. Lack of crisis preparedness

    Without a solid crisis management plan, even minor PR issues can spiral out of control, leading to long-term reputation damage.

    These challenges aren’t just theoretical—they have real consequences. But the good news? They’re also preventable. In the next section, we’ll explore how to spot brand reputation risks before they become costly mistakes.

    Is your brand reputation at risk? Here’s how to tell

    Brands often struggle to recognize reputation issues until they become costly. Here are key indicators that signal a brand reputation problem:

    • Declining Net Promoter Score (NPS) or Customer Satisfaction (CSAT): A downward trend suggests customers are less likely to recommend or engage with your brand.
    • Lower Brand Awareness Score: If fewer consumers recognize your brand, it signals weaker market presence and declining relevance.
    • Increasing negative sentiment in social listening tools: A rise in complaints, negative mentions, or critical discussions indicates growing reputation concerns.
    • Lower engagement on brand campaigns: If interactions are dropping despite increased marketing efforts, your messaging may not be resonating.
    • High customer churn rates: When customers leave at a higher rate citing brand perception as a factor, it’s a sign of declining loyalty.
    • Declining Customer Effort Score (CES): If customers find it harder to interact with your brand, they may disengage entirely.
    • Lack of clarity in customer feedback: If consumers struggle to articulate what your brand stands for, it signals weak positioning or inconsistent messaging.
    • Poor Corporate Reputation Index performance: A disconnect between brand image and public perception can damage credibility.
    • Inconsistent brand recognition across customer segments: If different audiences perceive your brand differently, it suggests misalignment in messaging.
    • Slow or ineffective responses to public relations crises: Delayed or poor handling of crises can amplify brand damage rather than contain it.

    If any of these signs sound familiar, it’s time to take a closer look at your brand reputation strategy. Let’s start by assessing where your biggest gaps may be.

    Brand reputation health check

    Answer these questions to see where your brand stands today:

    • Is there a gap between how we see our brand and how customers actually perceive it?
    • Are negative reviews or social media complaints increasing?
    • Is our messaging consistent across all channels and customer touchpoints?
    • Are we responding quickly and effectively to reputation risks?
    • Are we gaining visibility in the market, or are competitors overshadowing us?
    • Do customers find it easy or frustrating to interact with our brand? (Customer Effort Score)
    • Is our brand positively associated with credibility and influence? (Corporate Reputation Index)
    • Are we actively measuring brand sentiment over time?
    • How well do we handle customer complaints and feedback?
    • Do our brand values align with evolving cultural and societal expectations?
    • Are we prepared for reputation crises with a clear response plan?

    If you’re uncertain about any of these answers, it’s time to reassess your approach to brand reputation management. In the next section, we’ll explore the key elements of a strong reputation strategy.

    The one thing most brands overlook—but can’t afford to

    Traditional brand monitoring tools reveal what’s already happened, but they don’t explain why. Without a clear understanding of what’s driving audience perception, teams struggle to identify messaging misalignments, anticipate potential issues, and make informed adjustments. However, by capturing real-time feedback through customer insights, brands can refine messaging before problems arise.

    Reputation isn’t just about avoiding negative press—it’s about proactively shaping how your brand is perceived across every touchpoint. 

    A holistic approach to brand reputation includes:

    • Messaging and authenticity: Ensuring brand storytelling resonates with customer expectations.
    • Awareness and recognition: Testing brand recall and market positioning against competitors.
    • Crisis readiness: Monitoring potential reputation risks and developing proactive response strategies.
    • Customer experience and consistency: Evaluating how interactions build loyalty or create friction.
    • Corporate responsibility and ethics: Ensuring a brand’s values align with customer expectations on sustainability and inclusivity.

    Leading brands use customer insights to:

    • Listen beyond social analytics: Social platforms amplify extreme voices, distorting real customer sentiment. Testing messaging with real audiences prevents biased assumptions.
    • Test before launching: Brands that validate messaging and visuals with customers before going live prevent reputation missteps.
    • Refine brand positioning continuously: Companies that integrate ongoing customer feedback into their branding efforts ensure long-term resonance and credibility.
    • Monitor and adapt in real time: AI-powered sentiment analysis helps brands detect reputation risks early, so they can course-correct before issues escalate.

    By leveraging customer insights, brands move from reactive damage control to proactive reputation management. The next step? Applying this approach to build a stronger, more resilient brand.

    Brand reputation playbook: a blueprint for success

    In today’s landscape, reputation isn’t just managed—it’s engineered. The most resilient brands don’t leave perception to chance; they follow a strategic playbook to stay ahead. Here’s how to build a proactive, reputation-first brand strategy.

    Ensure your messaging resonates before it reaches the public

    • Run message resonance testing to gauge clarity, emotional impact, and alignment with expectations—so every campaign lands the way you intend.
    • Conduct first-impression tests to assess how customers perceive brand messages at a glance.
    • Use A/B testing, social listening, and qualitative research to compare messaging variations and uncover what truly connects with your audience.
    • Monitor competitor messaging to ensure your brand is differentiated in a crowded market.

    How UserTesting helps

    • Validate brand messaging with confidence: Use Live Conversations to conduct one-on-one interviews with real customers or run self-guided tests where participants react to your messaging in real time.
    • Capture first impressions and emotional responses: Run first-click tests or five-second tests to assess whether key messages stand out and align with customer expectations.
    • Optimize effectiveness with A/B testing: Use A/B tests to compare different versions of headlines, ad copy, taglines, and calls to action, and increase the success of these tests by vetting the alternates being tested, to determine which resonates best with your audience prior to launching.

    Strengthen brand consistency across every customer touchpoint

    • Conduct a brand consistency audit to test messaging across all platforms—before inconsistencies create confusion
    • Observe real customer interactions across websites, social media, and customer service touchpoints to identify misalignment
    • Run customer journey testing to ensure a seamless, unified experience across every brand interaction

    How UserTesting helps

    • Test messaging clarity and consistency across channels: Run multi-channel user tests, including real-world experiences, to evaluate whether brand messaging remains cohesive across websites, social media, email campaigns, and ads.
    • Identify inconsistencies in customer experiences: Use session replays and moderated interviews to observe how customers interact with different brand touchpoints and uncover gaps in consistency.
    • Ensure alignment in customer service interactions: Conduct customer support experience tests to assess whether service responses align with brand values and messaging.
    • Validate brand recall and recognition: Use brand perception tests to measure whether customers associate the right attributes with your brand across different platforms.
    • Unify the brand experience across international markets: Conduct global audience testing using the UserTesting Participant Network to ensure messaging is culturally relevant and consistent across regions.

    Crisis-proof your brand reputation

    • Run crisis simulation exercises to test your team’s ability to respond under pressure
    • Monitor public sentiment and industry trends to detect potential risks before they escalate
    • Develop a crisis response framework outlining clear steps for handling backlash and misinformation

    How UserTesting helps

    • Refine your response strategy in real time: Use Live Conversations to present different crisis scenarios and gauge audience reactions, refining your response strategy in real time
    • Track the impact of crisis communications: Use post-campaign feedback tests to assess how crisis communication efforts impact customer perception
    • Validate crisis messaging before going public: Conduct message testing on crisis statements to ensure the wording and tone align with customer expectations before a real crisis occurs

    Elevate brand advocacy and customer engagement

    • Encourage user-generated content (UGC) to enhance authenticity and organic reach
    • Build a customer advocacy program that rewards loyal customers for amplifying your brand message
    • Activate employee brand ambassadors to strengthen internal brand alignment and credibility
    • Track Brand Advocacy Score (BAS), Customer Referral Rates, and Social media mentions to measure impact

    How UserTesting helps

    • Test UGC effectiveness before publishing: Run preference tests to compare different types of UGC and see which resonates most with your audience
    • Ensure internal brand alignment: Conduct employee brand alignment testing to ensure internal teams understand and embody brand values in their messaging
    • Validate customer storytelling strategies: Use storytelling validation tests where customers react to different narrative styles to determine which fosters stronger brand affinity

    Continuously measure and refine brand perception

    • Establish a brand reputation dashboard tracking NPS, CSAT, Awareness Score, and Corporate Reputation Index over time
    • Benchmark against competitors to track shifts in perception and maintain a competitive edge
    • Conduct periodic reputation assessments to ensure long-term consistency in how your brand is perceived

    How UserTesting helps

    • Benchmark against competitors: Conduct competitive brand testing to compare your brand perception with competitors and uncover areas for differentiation
    • Track audience sentiment over time: Use QXscore™, UserTesting’s proprietary brand experience metric, to track shifts in perception and brand sentiment
    • Ensure messaging resonates with evolving audience expectations: Conduct longitudinal studies where you gather feedback from the same participants over time to monitor how perception shifts

    Leverage AI and human insights for smarter brand reputation management

    AI is transforming brand reputation management—helping brands detect risks, optimize messaging, and measure sentiment in real time. But while AI enhances speed and scale, human insights ensure authenticity and relevance.

    AI is a valuable tool for refining brand communications—accelerating feedback loops, detecting sentiment shifts, and optimizing messaging strategies. But while AI can surface patterns, only human insights reveal intent, emotion, and cultural relevance, ensuring brand messaging lands the right way.

    How AI helps strengthen brand communications

    • Accelerates content brainstorming: Generates messaging ideas that can be refined and prioritized through human testing to find the most impactful options.
    • Enhances test creation: Helps draft test plans and optimize participant screeners, ensuring brand teams collect the right audience insights.
    • Speeds up data analysis: Summarizes transcripts, flags recurring themes, and detects emotional responses, helping teams extract insights faster.
    • Still requires human validation: AI-generated content often sounds unnatural to customers. Testing with real audiences ensures messaging feels authentic and engaging.

    How UserTesting helps

    • Enhance speed and scale of brand testing: Use AI-powered sentiment analysis to extract insights from open-ended feedback faster
    • Detect subtle perception shifts: AI-driven friction detection pinpoints moments of hesitation in customer feedback, helping identify weak points in messaging
    • Summarize and analyze large datasets efficiently: Use AI-powered summarization tools to analyze thousands of video responses and survey results quickly, making it easier to identify trends and actionable insights

    How AI affects brand perception

    • Shapes customer interactions in real time: AI-powered chatbots and virtual assistants are judged as if they were human, meaning a cold or robotic response can weaken brand perception
    • Demands a fine-tuned brand voice: Automated interactions serve as digital brand representatives, making it critical to adjust tone and language to match brand identity
    • Reveals competitive insights: Testing AI-driven competitor experiences can highlight best practices while exposing potential risks in automated brand interactions

    How UserTesting helps

    • Evaluate AI-generated messaging and brand interactions before launch: use Live Conversations or preference tests to compare AI-generated copy, chatbot scripts, and automated interactions against human-created alternatives, ensuring they align with brand identity and customer expectations
    • Assess real-world customer reactions to AI-powered experiences: conduct usability tests on chatbots and virtual assistants to determine whether they feel natural, helpful, and brand-consistent, while also identifying points of friction or confusion
    • Benchmark AI-driven interactions against competitors: use competitive testing to compare customer sentiment and engagement with AI-powered brand experiences, revealing best practices and potential risks before implementing your own

    By following this playbook, your brand won’t just react to reputation shifts—it will lead the conversation. With UserTesting, brand teams can replace assumptions with real audience insights—ensuring every message, campaign, and customer experience builds trust, engagement, and long-term brand resilience.

    Customer success stories: Improving brand reputation with customer insights

    Leading brands don’t just plan for reputation management—they take action. Here’s how top companies like Microsoft, American Airlines, and Burberry used customer insights to strengthen their brand perception.

    Microsoft scales customer empathy to strengthen brand trust

    Microsoft wanted to shift from a product-first to a customer-first approach but struggled to embed customer empathy across teams. They needed a faster way to test messaging, branding, and digital experiences to ensure alignment with customer expectations.

    Solution

    Using UserTesting, Microsoft gathered real-time customer insights to:

    • Validate brand messaging across global audiences
    • Improve digital experiences by testing UX elements for clarity and engagement
    • Speed up decision-making with direct customer feedback

    Results

    • 5X faster decision-making, allowing teams to adapt messaging in real-time
    • Increased brand trust through customer-driven messaging
    • Stronger alignment between product development and customer needs

    Watch below to discover how Microsoft continuously builds brand trust through customer-centric decisions.

    American Airlines reinvents the digital experience to restore trust

    Customers were frustrated with American Airlines’ booking experience, leading to declining trust. Key issues included confusing navigation, friction in flight booking, and lack of clarity on multi-city trips and passport entry.

    Solution

    UserTesting helped American Airlines:

    • Benchmark against competitors to identify usability gaps in the booking process
    • Refine navigation for multi-city searches and passport entry
    • Improve engagement and clarity in key travel details

    Results

    • 15% improvement in QXscore, signaling stronger brand perception and usability
    • 37% increase in task completion rates, reducing customer frustration
    • Improved reputation as a customer-first airline

    Watch below to learn how American Airlines boosts customer loyalty through continuous testing and measurement of its digital experiences.

    Burberry transforms customer engagement through personalization

    Burberry wanted to strengthen customer loyalty but noticed low engagement with their app’s content, signaling a misalignment between customer expectations and digital experiences.

    Solution

    UserTesting provided real customer insights that helped Burberry:

    • Insights helped to refine content personalization to match customer preferences
    • Optimized in-app navigation to make key features more discoverable
    • Enhanced push notifications to drive meaningful customer interactions

    Results

    • 200% increase in customer interaction with personalized content
    • Stronger brand perception as a digital innovation leader
    • Higher app retention and engagement, reinforcing long-term loyalty

    Watch below to hear how Burberry boosts customer loyalty through personalization.

    Build brand reputation with insights, not assumptions

    The strongest brands don’t guess; they listen, test, and refine before perception becomes reality.

    The thriving brands don’t wait for a crisis to tell them how they’re perceived. They continuously validate their messaging, refine their positioning, and ensure they meet customer expectations before small gaps become major risks. In an era where reputation shifts instantly, insights aren’t optional—they’re a competitive advantage.

    The good news? You don’t have to guess. Leading brands use fast customer insights to shape brand perception, strengthen trust, and reinforce loyalty before launching major campaigns. By leveraging direct audience feedback, you can close the gap between how you want to be perceived and how you actually are, ensuring every message, campaign, and customer interaction builds lasting brand equity.

    Your brand will be shaped with or without your input. The question is, will you take control of the conversation?

    friction detection

    Get actionable insights today

    Uncover human insights that make an impact. Book a meeting with our Sales team today to learn more.

    Book a meeting
    © UserTesting 2025
    SOC security logo CSA security logo GDPR security logo